Sucheta Dalal :Rising bubble in the property market?
Sucheta Dalal

Click here for FREE MEMBERSHIP to Moneylife Foundation which entitles you to:
• Access to information on investment issues

• Invitations to attend free workshops on financial literacy
• Grievance redressal


You are here: Home » Column Topics » Financial Express » Rising bubble in the property market?
                       Previous           Next

Rising bubble in the property market?  

Jun 27, 2005


Every big bull run seems to lead to a property bubble, as confident investors and companies drive up prices by parking at least a part of their profits in real estate. In 1994-95, at the height of the primary market mania, listed companies raised vast quantities of money through Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) and rights issues. A large chunk of money raised was invested in property, creating a huge bubble, which burst just after the primary market in equities went dead.


Interestingly, the property market has remained subdued for exactly as long as the primary market remained dormant. Despite hefty and well-warranted sops on home loans and a low interest rate regime, the realty market took a decade to recover from the post-1995 slump. Suddenly now, property prices have zoom-ed, despite home loan rates having risen and increase in supply of good housing stock and land (in Mumbai, with the constant revision in floor space index and development of vast textile mill lands) and generous funding of builders and developers by banks and housing finance firms.


Leading builders would correctly argue that it is probably a more important barometer of economic health than the Sen-sex. After all, there is a worldwide bubble in real estate in all major cities of the world. In most of these markets, the boom is due to low interest rates and massive funding available to borrowers. Often, property investment is an alternative to the capital market.


But in India, the runaway increase in real-estate prices seems to sustain itself on the feel-good factor emanating from the liquidity-driven capital market bull run. Yet, the recent spurt in property rates, especially in Mumbai, lend credence to the suspicion that lenders, builders and land-owners are creating a vicious cycle, where they will have to keep pushing up prices to keep the funding alive. Consider the signals. Indiabulls Financial Services, which recently raised large cash from investors, started India Properties, as a joint venture with Farallon Capital, to acquire Jupiter Mills of the National Textile Corporation in Mumbai for Rs 276.6 crore. This was followed by an even more stunning purchase, of NTC’s second mill, a 17.5 acre property, at Rs 702 crore by the DLF group of Delhi. The sale of two others, Elphin-stone and Kohinoor Mills, are expected to fetch similar prices.


Many believe the price of the DLF purchase will work only if property rates remain at the present high, or rise further. But the notion that property rates will not be impacted by a significant increase is supply is itself curious. Moreover, the sale of mill lands is the subject of litigation which could not be quashed, despite a concerted plea to the Supreme Court by the mill owner lobby. The Mumbai high court, which is hearing the case, has not stayed any construction on the land, but made it clear that it will be at the builders’ risk.


• Property prices have suddenly zoomed and the reasons seem unsustainable

• Banks and financing institutions may be getting dangerously extended


Property consultant Sunil Bajaj says these aggressive bids are only possible as the entire business is bankrolled several times over by housing finance companies and aggressive private banks. For instance, banks and housing finance institutions are fuelling and funding large bids by becoming partners in the real estate deals. The Leela Business Park and the Glaxo property deal in Mumbai are examples. Banks also fund construction by offering construction finance. And finance individuals to buy offices or apartments in the constructed property. Housing financiers, in a bid to book business, have increased their own risk, by offering to fund 100% of the property cost, including stamp duty and registration charges and more.


Is there an element of multiple funding or creative financing in these transactions? Are banks and institutions extending themselves dangerously here? Only the Reserve Bank of India can find out. But the warning bells are already ringing and the RBI needs to act now, to avoid a new set of bad loans in the housing and construction sector, with a negative impact across the economy. In the past, the central bank had issued general warnings and expressed concern about real estate funding. But sources say it was reacting more to the disclosure of specific frauds, such as the one involving United Bank of India (UBI), where a small businessman colluded with bank officials to siphon off over Rs 30 crore in the form of individual housing loans of Rs 1 crore each. Such localised frauds are a worry, but the bigger picture is getting even more worrisome.


-- Sucheta Dalal